Interesting. I tend to prefer Bat in a Blue Sky (Souten) over Stray Dog, but my memory of both is hazy since I lost them when I had to wipe my one shot collection. I think Bat has the better story though, though it is pretty simple and straightforward. Better execution then. Stray Dog does show some early signs of Arakawa's brilliance in planning action scenes though.ich1990 (post: 1279441) wrote:Stray Dog oneshot
It was pretty cool, but there is only so much you can do with one chapter and it tried to tackle an awful lot.
Souten no Koumori oneshot
Worse story, better fighting, more violence and nudity.
Demons of Shanghai oneshot
Comedy with a little fighting thrown in. Funny in a very FMA sense.
Fish and Chips (post: 1279529) wrote:Interesting. I tend to prefer Bat in a Blue Sky (Souten) over Stray Dog, but my memory of both is hazy since I lost them when I had to wipe my one shot collection. I think Bat has the better story though, though it is pretty simple and straightforward. Better execution then. Stray Dog does show some early signs of Arakawa's brilliance in planning action scenes though.
Demons of Shanghai is great and I wish Arakawa did something more with it.
ich1990 (post: 1279672) wrote:The reason I say that Bat has a worse story is because it has been done so many times.
"The assassin decides to give up his killing ways and finds a nice home to settle down in. The bad guys, however, track him down and try to to tie up this dangerous loose end. The assassin refuses to fight, of course, until his loved ones are threatened. Then, he must call upon his killing ways to save them."
Despite its unoriginality, I like Bat better. It has some awesome fight scenes and seems better laid out. Stray Dog had cool ideas, but it felt very cramped. Also, the fighting was quite rushed and compact.
Barack Obama has showed up and actually done something! I had figured he was thrown in for no good reason.
Puguni wrote:Fairy Tail 119. I would like to see a cosplay of Mistgun.
Things are heating up nicely for the final couple volumes.
Puguni wrote:What. That was my response to Fairy Tail 120. How do you feel about Mistgun now, UC?
Mistgun
The only decent character in Fairy Tail
Chapters 24-119
Rest in Peace
Return to Manga and Manga Reviews
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 173 guests