CAA: Christian Anime Alliance

I was just wondering if it would be alright to grave dig certain topics that don't apply to certain circumstances such as past events that has occured, debates or old releases. When I mean by that, is like a topic that doesn't really apply to the effects of changes in one's lifetime.

An example being a topic like "What's your favorite...(music, anime, book, etc.)?" or nearly anything in the Goof Off threads.

Well, the core of the answer is "do you think it will bother people?" In general, posting to a thread that's several months old will not bother anyone, and posting to a thread that's more than a year old (without new relevant news) will annoy people. The ages inbetween are less predictable; it depends on the nature of the thread in question. But I'm confident that if you use your best judgement there won't be any big problems. It's all about psychology. Predicting people's reactions may be difficult, but as we are a community of Christians, we ought to be tolerant and not rigid. We don't want anybody to feel afraid to post to threads that are "a little too old".

With the specific case of "what's your favorite X" threads, I personally don't see any harm in resurrecting those as much as a year or two back. Other people may have different opinions, of course, but I would not complain. When it comes to goof off, I'm inclined to believe that most people will be fine with a certain amount of light gravedigging, as long as they're still interested in the topic in the thread. If you gravedig a boring or frivolous thread, people might complain.

That is a good point. It would be hypocritical of me to say that I don'y sometimes get a little annoyed when some topics that are very old tend to annoy someone due to the regulations moreso than the actual fact it is old. However, like you said, it depends on the topic.

For instance, a thread such as "Let's Watch..." of something in 2007 would be considered something that could cause some conflict. But I was just wondering in the sense that there are some topics that I believe that could be revived due to how interesting it could be and just wanted to see if it would be alright with most. I'll use my better judgement.

Thanks Midi!

Sounds interesting

this helped me out too. Thanks MODori =P