Robin Firedrake (post: 1290642) wrote:I USED to like tae kwon do. That is until the instructor kicked me to the floor during sparring and kicked me BACK down before I had the slightest chance to get up. He did that repeatedly. With everyone. Including my siblings. Including the four year old.
Our focus was actual fights., not tournament style
dude...ain't nobody besides me doin' honest to goodness Karate-do anymore?
^ If you're gonna let two year olds (Yes they were as young as two) take your class DON'T keep kicking them back down. And no I don't think it's good instructing. It's more like ticking everyone off. Every time you were able to get up just a little faster and every time he'd kick you down faster. He was basically mocking you cause every time he kicked he'd say "Come on! Faster!" Lost half of his kid students that day and hasn't done it again.
You might try to Google a Christian Martial Art in your area. I was able to do that. It's harder for an instructor to be an out and out jerk when he/she loves the Lord and is focused on him, ya know?
Robin Firedrake (post: 1290774) wrote:^ If you're gonna let two year olds (Yes they were as young as two) take your class DON'T keep kicking them back down. And no I don't think it's good instructing. It's more like ticking everyone off. Every time you were able to get up just a little faster and every time he'd kick you down faster. He was basically mocking you cause every time he kicked he'd say "Come on! Faster!" Lost half of his kid students that day and hasn't done it again. But no I'm still not going back. I'm glad I got an excuse to leave. I never liked that stuff <_<
Yeah... That's the bad part. He IS a Christian and he still does that stuff.
. Sometimes it's just a label. I would encourage you to not give it up completely though. Don't let this guy knock you out of the wonderful world of martial arts.("It's harder for an instructor to be an out and out jerk when he/she loves the Lord and is focused on him, ya know?")
It's one teaching philosophy. For small children, it's overkill, and he's being ridiculous. But for older kids and especially adults, it simulates reality (you think someone's going to let you get up in a real fight?) and forces you to adapt and improvise. I think I would learn a lot from that sort of training. IT takes patience to learn that way, but it can be very useful. Obviously, his method isn't for you. That's fine. There are all sorts of martial arts instructors.
Roz wrote:You might try to Google a Christian Martial Art in your area. I was able to do that. It's harder for an instructor to be an out and out jerk when he/she loves the Lord and is focused on him, ya know?
Roz (post: 1291066) wrote:I agree that this could be an excellent teaching tool only for much older, upper belts and upper belt adults. Ones who actually might have a clue what to do about it. Trying to force them to fight and improvise at low levels would be pretty pointless I think since they haven't learned how to deal with that yet. After they get kicked down so many times they might be likely to just stay down, and then not come back to class. Some kids come to karate to learn how to deal with situations like that.
Kinda like (for inexperienced lower belts a very young children) handing them a stick of wood and telling them to make a fire without giving them the matches.
This is all IMHO.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 224 guests